Unpacking the term ‘reproductive rights’


Even before President Trump nominated Judge Amy Coney Barrett to replace the late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg as a new judge for the Supreme Court, every commentary on the nomination process said that abortion will be a major issue in the discussion. Be prepared. A phrase will be heard, “reproductive rights.” When this happens, dissect this phrase, in terms of logic and morality.

No one has doubts as to the meaning of “reproductive.” It is about human procreation.

“Rights” is the compelling word. Place it in the context of the emphasis on abortion. The basic question arises. Does anyone have the “right” to interfere with procreation in such a way that the unborn life deliberately is extinguished?

Pregnancies end naturally, due to physical circumstances beyond anyone’s control. Abortion is the intentional stopping of a developing new life, and abortion on demand is the ability to end a pregnancy, by decision, for a reason held often only by the mother, without question or qualification.

This ability is defended by arguing that the mother has this “right,” hence the term, “reproductive right.”

Is it a mother’s “right”? By extension, do medical professionals have the “right” to end a pregnancy, simply because a mother requests it.

Face facts. Under current American law, this “right” exists. Such has pertained since the U.S. Supreme Court in 1973 ruled that any woman, personally and privately, can decide to end her pregnancy, and no one legally can cancel or halt her decision.

The civil law, and Supreme Court rulings themselves, bind society, it is true, but they do not necessarily guarantee principles and ethics. Remember, American laws, and court rulings, explicitly protected slavery and enforced limiting the right to vote solely to males. Legal shortsightedness is part of history, as the Supreme Court itself has admitted on occasion. Judges are fallible human beings. Laws are human inventions.

It is altogether proper to peacefully question the wisdom or ethics of any court decision. Americans who object to, or criticize, present laws regarding abortion, aloud and persistently, absolutely are within their roles as citizens. This should be stressed when, in this moment, critics of present policy are denounced for being outrageously “out of place.”

By the same token, Americans who demanded in 1954 that the Supreme Court reverse itself regarding racial separation were not “out of place.”

Now, to the essential, what is a “right”? It is the freedom to decide, and to act, in a manner chosen because of personal deduction. The test, or the consequent restraint, comes when a decision jeopardizes the right of another.

This test is behind much of civilization and certainly of American law. It is our way of life, the heart of the American legal definitions of injury, obligation, liability and relief. It is why law enforcement exists, from the FBI’s investigations of spying by foreign powers to a local patrol officer’s watching a highway for traffic violations. No right is an open check to endanger the rights of others, especially the innocent.

As for abortion, no person, not even the mother, has the right utterly to destroy an essential right of another, surely not life itself.

What about persons convicted of crime? Are their rights curtailed? The operative words are “convicted” and “crime.” By a method studiously invoked as being the most thorough and fairest available under human ingenuity, a person is “convicted,” or found guilty, ultimately of trespassing upon the rights of another. Even at that, the system always, and carefully, respects the rights of the accused.

Penalties, including capital punishment itself, are applied in a process to assure that, in the future, the rights of everyone will be protected, and that a person found to have damaged the rights of another will not repeat the crime.

When the term “reproductive rights” is heard, take it apart. Analyze it.

This article comes to you from OSV Newsweekly (Our Sunday Visitor) courtesy of your parish or diocese.


Catholic News & Perspective

Provides information on the Church, the nation and the world from OSV, America's most popular and trusted national Catholic news source


Opening the Word: Awake ye sleepers

Friday, November 27, 2020
By: Timothy P. O'Malley We grow accustomed to even the most abnormal of situations. Since March 2020, the world has been under the threat of... Read More

Mary shows how to turn fear into invitation to hear God’s call, pope says

Wednesday, November 25, 2020
By: Carol Glatz There is no better way to pray than like Mary, who opened her heart to God with humility and trust, Pope Francis said. “It... Read More

I met a new friend at adoration: St. Thérèse

Monday, November 23, 2020
By: Scott Warden During a fundraiser that seems like it took place 18 years ago instead of 18 months — when it was safe to congregate by the... Read More

Opening the Word: The poor kingship of Jesus

Friday, November 20, 2020
By: Timothy P. O'Malley The aftershocks of election 2020 reverberate throughout the United States. Whatever presidential candidate will be... Read More

Navy dad, back home after 15 months away, surprises daughter at Catholic school

Wednesday, November 18, 2020
By: Michelle Martin The father-daughter reunion at a Catholic school in suburban Chicago was weeks in the making. U.S. Navy Petty Officer 1st Class... Read More

We all need to pray, ‘Lord, I need you’

Monday, November 16, 2020
By: Msgr. Owen F. Campion A priest tells this story. He was assigned as a pastor. His predecessor had left the job in disgrace. The parish was not... Read More

Opening the Word: An economy of gift

Friday, November 13, 2020
By: Timothy P. O'Malley We have grown so accustomed to moralistic accounts of prominent parables proclaimed in pulpits that we are likely to tune... Read More

Supreme Court hears arguments in foster care case with major religious freedom implications

Wednesday, November 11, 2020
By: Russell Shaw Some time in the early months of 2021, the Supreme Court will announce its decision in a closely watched case involving a critical... Read More

Without prayer, life can seem troublesome, tedious, pope says at audience

Monday, November 9, 2020
By: Carol Glatz VATICAN CITY (CNS) — Prayer has the power to take all those things in life that seem like a condemnation and turn them into... Read More

Opening the Word: The oil of desire

Friday, November 6, 2020
By: Timothy P. O'Malley Desire is vital to Catholicism. The human person is made to desire God, to long for union with our beloved... Read More

Online Giving

Online Giving

Secure and Convenient Donate now!